Social media events as a model for ‘triggering’ cognitive presence

According to pedagogical researchers Garrison, Anderson & Archer (2001) the first phase of cognitive presence in their Community of Inquiry model is a ‘triggering event’ which includes the recognition of a problem and a sense of puzzlement.  This initiates further exploration into possible solutions, ideally through collaborative information exchange and integration, before applying new ideas.

I’ve always considered ‘controversial’ questions as a good way of introducing a topic, forcing participants to reflect on an engaging issue as the first way of approaching a topic – to make it more ‘real’ to them. However, this doesn’t always come naturally, and perhaps we can learn something from viral social media events as triggering events, as the HumanMOOC has suggested in it’s final week. But can we engage our participants in the same way? Most successful social media events take off because of a commercially created video, big news story, strange event or brilliantly clever idea – not very easy to replicate!

Well one thing that viral social media events have in common is that they provoke a response by touching on real human issues.  The best events have framed controversial issues that relate to issues that are relevant to everyone – for example the “10 hours of walking in NYC as a woman” video that exposed everyday harassment or the Dove “Choose Beautiful” campaign that touched on issues of negative self-image. Such questions demand a response because they are relevant to everyone. Depending on the topic, it should be relatively easy to find material (whether it be a youtube video or opinion article) on a ‘controversial’ subject relevant to the subject that has a human ‘angle’, whilst being careful not to use offensive material or trivialising serious matters.

Another thing that popular social media events have in common is that they provide a simple template/structure for responses, making it easy for people to be involved in the conversation. For example the ice bucket challenge, which followed a common format – a video of a person having a bucket of water poured on their head after nominating 3 others for the same fate. #Likeagirl and #thisgirlcan used Twitter hashtags as the driving message behind the conversation, whilst campaigns like #notinmyname or #bringbackourgirls would ‘humanise’ the hashtag by using a ‘selfie’ with a self-penned version of the hashtag.

So the most successful social media events are good at provoking a human response, but also very good at making it quick and easy for people to respond.

Learning from Twitter hashtag events

There is also a lot to learn from the smaller spontaneous Twitter hashtags that popup from time-to-time. For example #nicerfilmtitles, where people changed one word in a film title to make it nicer (Snacks on a Plane, The Bourne Diplomacy) or others more open to comedic or topical interpretation such as #2015in5words, or #11thCommandment.
These hashtags are very popular for short periods of time, and quite often get picked up by celebrity tweeters. What I like about these is that they allow people to participate very easily, either by changing a single word, or providing a short snappy sentence. It also encourages people to write concisely, which is an important skill in academic writing.

Thinking about how to apply this concept to my own work, our online course participants are international researchers, so we try to avoid using humour too much, as there are many cultural differences and it’s easy to be misinterpreted (for example, my British sense of humour can be rather ironic and surreal). Here are some ideas that might work better:

Summarise your idea

I like the idea of getting participants to summarise their research idea or a research gap in a certain number of words (perhaps 7 or 8). This could happen via Twitter, or could be done within a forum or a tool such as padlet. This would be a good model for how they communicate their research ideas in the future, and I think this could lead organically to follow-up discussions between people with similar interests. There could also be a follow-up exercise where participants write a longer summary (perhaps an abstract).

Summarise learning

This concept could also be used as a way of testing participants understanding of key concepts, for example “summarise what you have learnt this week in 7 words”. This tests learning, conciseness and gives the student a chance to be creative. It’s also fun!

I tried replicating this on the HumanMOOC Twitter conversation with a #humanizedelearningin5words hashtag. Not particularly catchy, and It didn’t quite go viral, but we got some interesting contributions:


Twitter also allows for attaching images for extra impact – expand the tweets above to see these!

References

Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2001). Critical Thinking and Computer Conferencing:A Model and Tool to Assess Cognitive Presence. American Journal of Distance Education. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.533.3416&rep=rep1&type=pdf

“Watch This Woman Get Harassed 108 Times While Walking in New York City”, retrieved from Time website, 03/01/2016
http://time.com/3543632/street-harassment-hollaback-video/

“Here are Some of the Best Viral Campaigns of 2015”, retrieved from Small Business Trends website, 03/01/2016
http://smallbiztrends.com/2015/12/best-viral-campaigns-2015.html

45 Comments

  1. Laura Gibbs

    The #humanizedelearningin5words thing was one of my favorite things in #HumanMOOC. If I were to ever do a class with Twitter as a shared class space, I would do some games like that for sure. Fun, powerful, easy. Maybe they will use that in the next run of #HumanMOOC. I hope they will! :-)

    Reply
  2. aryne

    thanks for this article

    Reply
  3. Mariya

    Thank you for sharing this interesting blog

    Reply
  4. tita

    Thanks for the post

    Reply
  5. tita

    nice information

    Reply
  6. zoli zoli

    Thank you very much.

    Reply
  7. zianezo

    I like such topics.Thank you

    Reply
  8. zoli zoli

    It’s worth reading you

    Reply
  9. ziane

    Topic is really excellent.

    Reply
  10. zianezo

    .
    Topic is really excellent.

    Reply
  11. ziane

    I like such topics.Thank you

    Reply
  12. Baker ST

    Exceptional post however , I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this topic?
    I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more.
    Thank you!

    Reply
  13. TITA

    Nice blog. Thank you very much

    Reply
  14. Baker ST

    You have outdone yourself this time. It is probably the best, most short step by step guide that I have ever seen on net.

    Reply
  15. kamir bouchareb st

    nice good article

    Reply
  16. Ziane.ziane

    So beautiful ! Thank you !

    Reply
  17. fateh

    Very beautiful important and significant subjects

    Reply
  18. aryne

    Fabulous site…Thank you!
    is really informative and i’ll be grɑteful if ʏou keep writing in the future.

    Reply
  19. noor

    Fabulous site…Thank you!
    is really informative and i’ll be grɑteful if ʏou keep writing in the future.

    Reply
  20. noor

    Nice article.. thank you very much for spending the time to write this post.

    Reply
  21. aryne

    Nice article.. thank you very much for spending the time to write this post.

    Reply
  22. nassim

    Thank you very much for the information!

    est vraiment instructif et je serai reconnaissant si vous continuez à écrire à l’avenir.

    Reply
  23. simon
  24. simon

    fll nice article

    Reply
  25. ziane

    I am browsing this website dailly and get nice facts from here all the time.

    Reply
  26. zoulikha

    I am browsing this website dailly and get nice facts from here all the time.

    Reply
  27. ziane.ziane

    I am browsing this website dailly.

    Reply
  28. zoli zoli

    get nice facts from here all the time.

    Reply
  29. GTU

    Nice Article thanks for your valuable information post

    Reply
  30. zoulikha

    Thank you so much for writing this. I’ve never had such an eloquent description for what I do. Much to think about

    Reply
  31. ziane

    Thank you so much for writing this. I’ve never had such an eloquent description for what I do. Much to think about

    Reply
  32. zoli zoli

    Thank you so much for writing this. I’ve never had such

    Reply
  33. ziane

    Thank you so much for writing this. I’ve never had such an eloquent think about

    Reply
  34. kamir bouchareb st

    good thanks for this

    Reply
  35. zoli zoli

    Very valuable information.

    Reply
  36. زوليخة

    Thank you for sharing it with us.

    Reply
  37. zianez

    Thank for you .

    Reply
  38. ziane

    Very valuable information.

    Reply
  39. kamir bouchareb st

    thanks for this

    Reply
  40. kamir bouchareb st

    very good thanks

    Reply
  41. amroune

    bu siteyi seviyorum. iyi jbo

    Reply
  42. amroune soumia

    Très beau travail
    visitez nous

    Reply
  43. GTU

    Thank you for sharing
    GTU

    Reply
  44. bahi

    The information provided on this topic has been very helpful.
    Thank you for the useful information.

    Reply
  45. kamir bouchareb st

    gooooooooooooood

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.