So week 1 of the Human MOOC required participants to do some reflections on the pros and cons of using instructor videos in online courses. We were also required to show competency in demonstrating “usage of [an] interactive educational tool to connect with learners”. One of the reasons I like (and am simultaneously terrified of) this MOOC is the choice of ‘stream’ of ‘garden’ path. The stream path offers set exercises to complete. The guidelines suggested using two tools – an audio tool called ‘voice thread’ and an ipad app called ‘FlipGrid’ where you can have collaborative discussions with short video clips.
The online courses I’m involved in are for participants in developing countries, so we have to be very conscious of bandwidth. Whilst some of our participants could have excellent broadband (and we know some have), many have poor or intermittent connections. In our last research writing course we had participants from Yemen, Sierra Leone, Somalia and Sudan.
Fortunately, the ‘Garden’ path means being able to interpret the exercises using whatever tools we decide are appropriate. So I thought I would use the most low-bandwidth tool I could find. One tool that I have been meaning to properly trial is called ‘Tricider’. This allows people to collaborate and argue/prioritise about different ideas. So I thought this might be an interesting platform to collaboratively ‘reflect’ on the pros and cons of instructor videos.
Firstly, I set up a free Tricider page, set a question and added some basic pro/cons ideas. I then sent out an invite on the #HumanMOOC hashtag (one of the best things about HumanMOOC is the discussion happening between participants outside of Canvas, where the course is based).
Ok, how about collaborating with tricider to decide pros/cons of videos in online courses? https://t.co/njspZHnSrN @OnlineCrsLady #HumanMOOC
— Andy Nobes (@andy_nobes) December 16, 2015
I got some great comments and ideas from my fellow participants (most of which know a lot more about online pedagogy than I do). It was kind of like a focused crowdsourcing of a group of online educators :). Here are the results:
Ok, now the first observation is that Tricider might not be the best tool for a simple ‘pro/con’ argument over a single point (How essential are videos in online learning). Perhaps I could have worded this differently, or perhaps set up two separate Tricider pages with “What are the advantages of videos for online learning?” and “What are the disadvantages of using videos in online learning?”. Tricider worked well as a collaborative tool, but the results don’t display as nicely as I would have liked, so here is my breakdown of what I feel I have learnt from this ‘reflection’:
Some Pros of using videos:
- Video is a powerful visual means to express our identity – it would be a waste not to utilise this medium if we have the opportunity.
- Video can be more nuanced than text communication – i.e. through facial expression, tone of voice etc.
- It can be culturally important to have non-textual communication, or at least see the face of the person you are communicating with.
- Video isn’t necessarily time consuming. If done properly, short videos can be reused again in future courses.
- Videos do not necessarily need to look ‘nice’ to be effective. A simple video shot on a webcam can be just as human, perhaps even more human than a polished video production.
- Making mediocre quality videos can also encourage students to try it out themselves!
- Videos can be a window on the instructor’s passion for the subject, which may not come through in text.
- Videos aren’t necessaily encouraging passivity – they can be signposts/triggers to exploration and inquiry (if done ‘well’, of course).
Some Cons of using videos:
- Human presence can be achieved without video (e.g. images/audio).
- Video is not necessarily a replacement for F2F presence – social interaction online can be as good, e.g. lively forums, social media and other asynchronous activities).
- A short ‘hello!’ video can make teachers think they have ticked the ‘human presence’ box before the course has begun.
- Video can be high bandwidth, so not ideal for developing countries – audio can be used as an alternative (but we could also provide both).
- Making videos can be time consuming (especially for first-timers and people outside their comfort zone)*.
- Videos can have a limited lifespan and can be difficult to change content (sure, you can make re-useable videos if done well, but does this risk making them ‘generic’ and therefore less human?).
- Writing does not have to be impersonal! Simple text writing can have character and humanity (although this too requires skill).
- “Some topics lend themselves to visual presentation” – this is certainly the case with the research writing courses my organisation runs. Scientific writing methods tend to be quite a fact-based academic subject that’s best explained through text examples, quotes and links.
In conclusion I would say that video can be an excellent addition to online learning, if well thought-out and well planned. However, you have to weigh up the ROI of spending the time to make video content. My organisation is very small, with limited time and resources, and in context of training developing country researchers, videos are an optional addition that could be worth trialling further if they add value to the course. Our courses are designed to be extremely low-bandwidth and so we will need to focus on social learning through activities that encourage learner-learner interaction, while continuing to improve and build on our teacher-learner collaborative activities such as peer assessment exercises.
* I have recent experience of trying video for the first time on a MOOC with over 1000 participants. Myself and my colleague in India attempted to record a Google Hangout hosted video introduction, which ended up taking nearly two hours, due to the number of takes. Here is an outtake from our attempts (the idea was for us to introduce ourselves one after the other):
nice information
Thank you very much for the information!
very good thank you
http://virtuelcampus.univ-msila.dz/fll
fll nice article
good article thanks
thanks for the last information
merci pour cet formation
m4ly4q
cid2lu
rlnwrq
Responsible For The Tiktok Pornstars Budget?
12 Ways To Spend Your Money tiktok pornstars
Why We Enjoy Xxx Of Pornstar (And You Should Also!) premium
9uan0z
5rsg2t
rx0ajt
wbiqld
cgpdpb
1ninmb
Are Text Rewritter The Best There Ever Was? Wordai
Is GSA SER Help As Vital As Everyone Says? gsa ser coupon
The 10 Most Terrifying Things About CSGO Most Profitable Cases Wildfire Case
What Is The Secret Life Of Agency SEO Software seo ranker agency
The 12 Best Egg Vibrator Uk Accounts To Follow On Twitter egg vibrators For sale
The Most Prevalent Issues In CSGO Case Battles Case Fracture (Swanmei.Com)
Are Case Battle CS GO The Best Thing There Ever Was? Counter strike Global offensive
20g8l9
p3hft6
Link Building Services: Myths And Facts Behind Link Building Services seo Services in uk
CS GO New Cases: What’s The Only Thing Nobody
Is Talking About Chroma Case
It’s Time To Increase Your Solid SEO Tools Options solid seo tools
7 Things You’ve Never Knew About What CSGO Cases To Invest In Glove case
Why Nobody Cares About Mesothelioma Legal Mesothelioma lawsuit
10 Facts About Seo Optimization That Will Instantly Get You Into A Great Mood
search Optimization
The Top Reasons People Succeed In The CSGO Gambling Sites Industry counter Strike
15 Terms Everyone Within The Fleshlight Sleeve Industry Should Know fleshlight Review
See What Online Charity Shop Uk Clothes Tricks The Celebs Are Using online charity shop
uk clothes, http://www.healthndream.com,
14 Smart Strategies To Spend Leftover How To Get CS GO Cases Budget Kilowatt case
20 Fun Infographics About Asbestos Lawsuit Asbestos Litigation
10 Tell-Tale Symptoms You Need To Look For A New Sex Machine Near Me sex
machine near me (Candida)
5 Clarifications Regarding Sex Machines sex machine in my area (Josefina)
Guide To Asbestos Legal: The Intermediate Guide For Asbestos Legal asbestos Legal
Why You’ll Want To Learn More About Mesothelioma Law Firm Asbestos Litigation
Small Espresso Machine The Process Isn’t As Hard As You Think milk Frother
What Is Best Sex Toy For Clit And How To Use What Is
Best Sex Toy For Clit And How To Use clitoral vibrator For women
Is Clitorial Stimulators Really As Vital As Everyone Says?
Clitorial stimulators
The Most Advanced Guide To Cheapest Anal Sex Toys sex
You’ll Never Be Able To Figure Out This Mobility Scooter Folding’s Benefits Scooter folding
From The Web The 20 Most Amazing Infographics About Cheap Rabbit Vibrators Womens Rabbit vibrator sex toy
Who Is Anal Sex Toy Price Uk And Why You Should Take A Look
womens anal toys [https://Coolpot.stream/]
How To Make An Amazing Instagram Video About Sex Machines Price uk sex machine
15 Top Pinterest Boards From All Time About Shop Anal
Sex Toy Price
20 Trailblazers Lead The Way In What CSGO Cases Have Butterfly Knives Operation riptide Case
Getting Tired Of Rabbit Vibrator Sex Toys?
10 Inspirational Sources That Will Bring Back Your Love Best Rabbit Vibrator
What’s Holding Back The Folding Mobility Scooter Uk
Industry? folding mobility scooter near me (diggerslist.com)
20 Things You Should Be Asking About CSGO Cases Websites Prior
To Purchasing CSGO Cases Websites case clutch (quebec-quebec.net)
An Easy-To-Follow Guide To Choosing The Right CSGO Cases Opening shattered web Case
What Is Clitorus Vibrator And How To Use What Is
Clitorus Vibrator And How To Use Clitorus Vibrator
15 Weird Hobbies That Will Make You More Effective At Wall Electric Fireplace In Wall Electric Fire
CSGO Cases Value: What’s New? No One Is Talking About Spectrum case (jisuzimu.com)
14 Cartoons On Best Sex Machine To Brighten Your Day sex machines price
uk; wecan.skybbs.biz,
Where Are You Going To Find Sex Machines Online Store One Year From Right Now?
uk sex machines
20 Resources To Make You Better At Fleshlight Best top fleshlight (Lincoln)
The Top Reasons People Succeed With The Vintage Couch For Sale Industry Discount Sofa showroom
One L Shaped Couches For Sale Success Story You’ll Never Believe small sectionals For sale
10 Things People Get Wrong About The Word “Wall Mounted Fireplace.” Wall hung Electric fires uk
20 Questions You Should Always Ask About GSA SER Download Before You Buy GSA SER Download buy gsa ser
This Is The Defra Exempt Multi Fuel Stoves Case Study You’ll
Never Forget wood heater
5 Arguments What Is The Best Folding Mobility
Scooter To Buy Is Actually A Good Thing buy affordable mobility scooter
Ten Startups That Are Set To Change The Rabbit Vibrators Uk Industry For
The Better cheap
This Is The Ugly The Truth About Bean To Cup Coffee Machine Sale best bean to cup coffee machine; test.gitaransk.ru,
A. The Most Common Nespresso Machines Uk Debate Could Be As Black Or White As
You May Think Travel Nespresso Machine
10 Strategies To Build Your Ford Car Key Replacement Empire Ford Focus Replacement Key Cost Uk
Guide To Double Glazing Repairs Near Me: The Intermediate Guide On Double Glazing Repairs Near Me
double glazing repairs near me (Raymundo)
15 Things You Don’t Know About Ghost Alarm Installation autowatch ghost 2 installers near me
The Three Greatest Moments In Fridge For Sale History Fridges for sale
How Bmw Key Fob Replacement Cost Became The Top Trend On Social Media Bmw Key Fob Replacement Cost
Why Everyone Is Talking About Erb’s Palsy Lawyer Right Now Erb’s Palsy Lawsuit
Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliners Tools To Streamline Your Everyday Lifethe Only Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliners Trick That Every Person Should Learn avon glimmerstick eyeliner (Lula)
10 Inspiring Images About Anal Toy In My Area arse
17 Reasons To Not Avoid Key Cut For Car key cut for car (Dudoser.com)
20 Things You Need To Be Educated About Accident Attorney fatal accidents attorney (Jacquie)
The 10 Scariest Things About Leather Recliners For Sale leather Recliners for sale
Think You’re Perfect For Doing Anal Fleshlight? Take This Quiz adult fleshlight, Augusta,
Pingback: 7 Helpful Tips To Make The Profits Of Your Bmw Key Fob Replacement Cost – stg.diocanto.com
What’s The Current Job Market For Renault Replacement Key Card Professionals Like?
renault replacement key card (http://www.stes.tyc.edu.tw/xoops/modules/profile/userinfo.php?uid=1176070)
20 Misconceptions About Door Fitting Luton: Busted double Glazing windows near me